About the Greysheet Marketplace

Catalog

Group

Series

CAC

Grading Authority

Sale Format

Seller

Sort By

U.S. Coins for Sale/Bid

Greysheet Marketplace: Nickels, Shield Nickels Proof (1866–1883)

Catalog

Group

Series

CAC

Grading Authority

Sale Format

Seller

Sort By

Grid View

List View

1869 5c PCGS PR67
eye-icon 23
Seller - Charleston Rare Coins
$ 3,950.00
Buy It Now
1870 5c PCGS PR65
eye-icon 37
Seller - Heritage Auctions
525.00
Auction Ends 12/15/2025
1870 5c PCGS PR64
eye-icon 24
Seller - Grand Rapids Coins LLC
$ 679.88
Buy It Now
Ad Banner
1871 5c PCGS PR63
eye-icon 34
Seller - Heritage Auctions
360.00
Auction Ends 12/15/2025
1874 5c PCGS PR67
eye-icon 206
Seller - DLRC
$ 3,006.25
Buy It Now
1874 5c PCGS PR67 CAM
eye-icon 187
Seller - DLRC
$ 7,215.00
Buy It Now
1875 5c NGC PR65
eye-icon 27
Seller - DLRC
$ 925.00
Buy It Now
Ad Banner
1875 5c PCGS PR64
eye-icon 64
Seller - DLRC
$ 601.25
Buy It Now
1876 5c NGC PR67 CAM
eye-icon 17
Seller - Heritage Coin Wholesale
$ 3,000.00
Buy It Now
1880 5c NGC PR66
eye-icon 38
Seller - Heritage Auctions
490.00
Auction Ends 12/15/2025
1881 5c PCGS PR67 CAM
eye-icon 194
Seller - DLRC
$ 5,411.25
Buy It Now
Ad Banner
1